Press one of the expand buttons to see the full text of an article. Later press collapse to revert to the original form. The buttons below expand or collapse all articles.
March 23, 2011 permalink
Kelly Wang is a citizen of China and her three-year-old daughter Tanya is a Canadian. A race is on between immigration and the passport office to see whether Tanya can accompany Kelly to China when she is deported. If Tanya stays behind she will be seized by children's aid and fostered or adopted. If she gets to go to China with her mother, they face harsh treatment in China where single mothers are not tolerated. All in the best interest of the child.
Single mom faces deportation to China
Grieving single mom Kelly Wang will be deported to China next week and vows not to leave her daughter behind.
Wang, 30, is slated to take her girl, Tanya, 3, a Canadian citizen, to the Chinese embassy, on St. George St., to obtain a passport for the trip home. The child also requires a visitor’s visa for the March 30 flight.
She is concerned Tanya may not receive her travel documents in time and will have to remain in Canada with the Children’s Aid Society.
“I am worried about my daughter,” Wang sobbed on Monday. “I don’t want to leave her behind in Canada.”
Wang claimed she will be ostracized in China for being an “unwed mother.”
The graphic designer arrived in Canada as a refugee claimant in 2004 and lost her appeals in 2007.
“I am not leaving Canada without Tanya,” Wang said. “I am shaking like a leaf and I have not been able to eat or sleep.”
She said Tanya hasn’t been told of the deportation to spare the child from becoming stressed out prior to leaving the country.
Wang’s immigration consultant, Roy Kellogg, said Chinese authorities will impose a fine of $140,000 on his client for having a child out of wedlock.
“Tanya will have to renounce her Canadian citizenship to attend school,”
Kellogg said. “She is required to have permission from the Chinese government to bear a child.”
He said if a fine isn’t paid, Tanya will be seized by the government and placed for adoption.
Wang has an application for humanitarian and compassionate review outstanding.
Officials of the Canada border services said the merit of each refugee case is decided by a board which has the last word on a case. A newcomer has the opportunity a make a refugee claim and subsequent appeal, but must leave Canada if there is a negative outcome.
Source: Toronto Sun
Addendum:Within days here is another case of a country deporting a young citizen with the threat of foster/adoptive care.
Wait, What? U.S. Deports 4-Year-Old U.S. Citizen
The hot-button issue of granting citizenship to the children of immigrants that are born in the U.S. has a new poster child. Everybody meet four-year-old Emily Samantha Ruiz, a Long Island girl who was deported to Guatemala by the U.S. on March 11—despite being a totally legal citizen of the United States.
Emily's parents—who are both illegal immigrants from Guatemala—sent their older child to their homeland for the winter in the hopes the warmer climate would alleviate the little girl's asthma. On the 11th she was supposed to come back accompanied by her grandfather, who had a valid work visa to enter the country. But when their flight to JFK was delayed and sent to Dulles, Immigration officials noticed that Emily's grandfather (whose name has not been released) had entered the country illegally in the 90s and detained him (at which point he apparently had a panic attack and was taken to the hospital).
This left Emily in a legal limbo of sorts. For more than a day she was detained in federal custody in Washington while her parents, who speak only a little English, tried to figure out what was going on.
At which point versions of the story vary. Customs officials say they offered Emily's father Leonel Ruiz a chance to either pick up Emily at Dulles or to have the girl return to Guatemala with her grandpa. But if Ruiz had gone to pick up his daughter, he would have run the risk of being detained himself. And anyway, according to him, he was never offered that choice. Instead, he says, an official told him that Emily could either go back to Guatemala or be put into the custody of Virginia—an idea that terrified the Ruiz family.
“We were very worried, and my wife was crying and crying at what was happening,” Ruiz told the Times. Ruiz's lawyer, David Sperling, is now planning on sending a staffer to retrieve the girl in the coming days.
Meanwhile the U.S. is defending its actions saying that the Customs and Border Protection agency "strives to reunite children who are citizens with their parents. If the parents decide not to take custody of their children, the CBP works with other agencies to guard the security and the well-being of these children. That includes handing them over to other families.”
This story breaks as the issue of automatic citizenship for those born on U.S. soil has been much in the news. Last week Arizona came thisclose to pushing a measure that would have brought the issue to the Supreme Court, and other states (like Kansas and California) have flirted with laws to make automatic citizenship harder for children.